Cybersecurity Must Be Free
Full Title or Meme
The arts and sciences of Cryptography or secret writing depends on secrecy. Those with a secret to hide want to protect it. Those that can break Cryptography do not want their adversaries to know about that capability.
- As long as secret writing has existed, adversaries have tried to detect when it is used and then to break the code and read the secret information.
- During the second World War, the Allies were able to read many of the German and Japanese encrypted messages. It was critical to the continued availability of this that the Allies not let their adversaries know about the capability because that would cause them to further strengthen their encoding methods and so close off the information. This information was not released until 1974.
- The NSA and the UK had both created public key cryptography techniques but treated them with the same level of protection that was given to the Ultra Secrets of WWII. When the Diffie Hellman paper was published in 1976, they were appalled that such information was public and warned the IEEE that allowing the export of such information was a "exporting technical articles on encryption and cryptology—a technical field, which is covered by Federal Regulations, viz: ITAR (International Traffic in Arms Regulations, 22 CFR 121-128)." And the presenting the information in an international symposium could be prosecuted. The paper was presented. The prosecution did not occur.
The US Government seems to be of two minds on sharing Cybersecurity information with industry:
- The DHS hosts the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Agency (CISA) which has a policy of Information Sharing and Awareness. All of the information is hosted on public data bases maintained by MITRE.
- The DoD operating thru the joint command of the NSA and the CSS investigates and hides cyberattacks that it can use for Offensive operations like that against the Iranian Nuclear Bomb initiative.
Biden's Executive Order on Cybersecurity is quite clear that it expects industry to share information with the government, but makes no statement about the government sharing information with industry.
- Frederick William Winterbotham, The Ultra Secret Harper & Row (1974-01-01) ISBN 978-0060146788
- Whitfield Diffie, Martin E. Hellman, New Directions in Cryptography. (1976-11). IEEE Transactions on Information Theory. 22 (6): 644–654.
- Henry Corrigan-Gibbs (December 2014). "Keeping Secrets". Stanford Magazine – Stanford Alumni Association. (2014-11). https://alumni.stanford.edu/get/page/magazine/article/?article_id=74801