Difference between revisions of "Dimensions in Physics"

Revision as of 22:12, 8 February 2024 (view source) Tom (talk | contribs) (→‎Problems) ← Older edit		Revision as of 22:17, 8 February 2024 (view source) Tom (talk | contribs) (→‎Solution) Newer edit →
Line 83:		Line 83:
	==Solution==		==Solution==
−	The following will shown one way to get the right answer for the split particle paradox.	+	The following will shown one way to get the right answer for the split photon paradox as describe by Anton Zeilinger in the problem of non-locality as described above with a simple inversion of what we count as reality.
	* There are (at least) two more dimensions that need to be considered; I will call them Energy and Momentum. While this is suggestive of my thoughts, I want to be clear that we could easily pick other names for them. The two are associated with the things that are not (always) a part of our sensible reality, which is limited to 4-space.		* There are (at least) two more dimensions that need to be considered; I will call them Energy and Momentum. While this is suggestive of my thoughts, I want to be clear that we could easily pick other names for them. The two are associated with the things that are not (always) a part of our sensible reality, which is limited to 4-space.
	* These dimensions should not be consider spacial in the sense of the first three in that continuity is not present and the metric might be something we have not considered before. Going with the idea that God created the integers and nothing else in Mathematics, I will stick with integers as the metric.		* These dimensions should not be consider spacial in the sense of the first three in that continuity is not present and the metric might be something we have not considered before. Going with the idea that God created the integers and nothing else in Mathematics, I will stick with integers as the metric.

---

Revision as of 22:17, 8 February 2024

Full Title or Meme

Beyond the 3 space dimensions and 1 time dimension other dimensions have been proposed to deal with issues not addressed in these 4.

Context

In understanding physics, dimensions play a crucial role in describing physical quantities.

The common use of calculus in Mathematics assumes continuity, the real world can surprise us with its discrete and varied dimensions. Physics bridges this gap by ensuring that equations remain dimensionally consistent, allowing us to explore the universe with mathematical precision.^[1]

1. Dimensional Analysis

  - The dimension of any physical quantity expresses its dependence on the base quantities (such as length, mass, time, etc.). Each dimension is represented by a symbol (or a power of a symbol) corresponding to the base quantity.
  - For instance:
    - Length has dimension **L** or **L^1**.
    - Mass has dimension **M** or **M^1**.
    - Time has dimension **T** or **T^1**.
  - We can express the dimension of any physical quantity as:
    \[ \text{Dimension} = L^a M^b T^c I^d \Theta^e N^f J^g \]
    where \(a\), \(b\), \(c\), \(d\), \(e\), \(f\), and \(g\) are powers associated with each base quantity.
  - Quantities with dimensions that can be written with all seven powers equal to zero (i.e., \(L^0 M^0 T^0 I^0 \Theta^0 N^0 J^0\)) are called **dimensionless** or **pure numbers**.

1. Continuity and Dimensionality

  - In mathematics, we often assume continuity. However, in the real world, physical dimensions need not always be continuous.
  - For example, consider motion. We postulate that motion is continuous, but this assumption doesn't necessarily hold in reality.
  - Physicists use square brackets around the symbol for a physical quantity to represent its dimensions. For instance:
    - If \(r\) represents the radius of a cylinder and \(h\) represents its height, we write \([r] = L\) and \([h] = L\) to indicate that both dimensions are lengths.
    - Surface area (\(A\)) has dimensions \(L^2\), and volume (\(V\)) has dimensions \(L^3\).
    - Mass (\(m\)) has dimensions \(M\), and density (\(\rho\)) has dimensions \(M/L^3\).

3. Dimensional Consistency

  - Any mathematical equation involving physical quantities must be dimensionally consistent.
  - Rules for dimensional consistency:
    - Every term in an expression must have the same dimensions.
    - Adding or subtracting quantities of differing dimensions is nonsensical (like adding apples and oranges).
    - Equations must have the same dimensions on both sides.

(1) 1.4 Dimensional Analysis | University Physics Volume 1 - Lumen Learning. https://courses.lumenlearning.com/suny-osuniversityphysics/chapter/1-4-dimensional-analysis/.

(2) 2.2: Units and dimensions - Physics LibreTexts. https://phys.libretexts.org/Bookshelves/University_Physics/Book%3A_Introductory_Physics_-_Building_Models_to_Describe_Our_World_%28Martin_Neary_Rinaldo_and_Woodman%29/02%3A_Comparing_Model_and_Experiment/2.02%3A_Units_and_dimensions.

(3) 6.1: An Analytic Definition of Continuity - Mathematics LibreTexts. https://bing.com/search?q=do+all+physical+dimensions+need+to+be+continuous.

(4) 1.7: Limits, Continuity, and Differentiability. https://math.libretexts.org/Bookshelves/Calculus/Book%3A_Active_Calculus_%28Boelkins_et_al.%29/01%3A_Understanding_the_Derivative/1.07%3A_Limits_Continuity_and_Differentiability.

Kaluza–Klein is a classical unified field theory of gravitation and electromagnetism built around the idea of a fifth dimension beyond the common 4D of space and time and considered an important precursor to string theory. In their setup, the vacuum has the usual 3 dimensions of space and one dimension of time but with another microscopic extra spatial dimension in the shape of a tiny circle. Gunnar Nordström had an earlier, similar idea. But in that case, a fifth component was added to the electromagnetic vector potential, representing the Newtonian gravitational potential, and writing the Maxwell equations in five dimensions.

Problems

1. For the Schrödinger equation to work, the space is typically defined as only piece-wise continuous, but a single photon may travel for a billion years or more, which seems to imply that all of 4-space must be continuously differentiable, not just in little patches.
2. Spooky Action at a Distance was what Eisntein called non-locality in QM. Here we will look at violations of Bell's Inequalities are summarized nicely in a popularizations by Anton Zeilinger^[2] and in the Scientific American^[3] which shows how Anton Zeilinger and others were able to
3. Dark Matter seems to be more prevalent than Matter that is sensible to humans as real. Since more is not sensible than sensible, it would make more sense to just assume that no Matter is directly sensible to humans, but just the effects of that matter that is associated with the Schrödinger equation.
4. Dark Energy is more nebulous even than Dark Matter. Dark energy is an unknown form of energy that pervades the cosmos. Its primary effect is to drive the accelerating expansion of the universe. Using the lambda-CDM model of cosmology, dark energy constitutes 68% of the total energy in the observable universe today. But the above item deals with Dark Matter and Einstein tells us that if c = 1 then E = m. Therefore i conclude that the thing driving the universe apart is not energy conservation, but momentum conservation. What is also interesting that if the density of momentum (along with everything else in the universe) is tending towards zero density. That really sounds a lot like the second law to me.

Modeling

"Mathematical models power our civilization—but they have limits." Models are not reality. As we humans try to model ever more complex part of reality, like fluid flow and brain surgery, we inevitably come to real world phenomena that the model fails to predict.^[4] In those cases it is a common practice to switch to discrete or perturbation techniques.

It’s hard for a neurosurgeon to navigate a brain. A key challenge is gooeyness. The brain is immersed in cerebrospinal fluid; when a surgeon opens the skull, pressure is released, and parts of the brain surge up toward the exit while gravity starts pulling others down. This can happen with special force if a tumor has rendered the skull overstuffed. A brain can shift by as much as an inch during a typical neurosurgery, and surgeons, who plan their routes with precision, can struggle as the territory moves.

The Three Spacial Dimensions

There is no Matter/Energy or Momentum in these dimension, only the information contained in the Schrödinger equations occupies space. That is not to say the the effects of the collapse of the wave equation is not noticeable in 3-space, only that they are only visible as a part of that collapse. All we see are the observables, that should be obvious by its name. The only reason that continuity is a good description of these dimensions, is that there are no individual pieces (parts) in them, not matter/energy, not momentum.

The Fourth Dimension - Time

The conjugate value to time in Quantum Mechanics is energy, which is supposed to be the conserved quantity from Nöther's Theorem.

What i would like to consider is that the conserved quantity corresponding to time is information.

Types of Information

• Laplace - the clockwork universe is set in motion and runs deterministically by itself (Laplace's daemon)
• Gaussian - error bounds prevent us from make any exact measurement
• Boltzmann statistics of distinguishable (known) particles
• Planck & Bose - statistics of indistinguishable particles
• Pauli & Dirac - statistics of particles subject to exclusion principle
• Fisher - population statistics
• Shannon - information content

Entropy

The entropy of the universe is constantly increasing. The second law of thermodynamics states that the state of entropy of the entire universe, as an isolated system, will always increase over time. Energy always flows downhill, and this causes an increase of entropy. Entropy is the spreading out of energy, and energy tends to spread out as much as possible. It flows spontaneously from a hot (i.e. highly energetic) region to a cold (less energetic) region. As a result, energy becomes evenly distributed across the two regions, and the temperature of the two regions becomes equal. The same thing happens on a much larger scale. The Sun and every other star are radiating energy into the universe. However, they can’t do it forever. Eventually the stars will cool down, and heat will have spread out so much that there won’t be warmer objects and cooler objects. Everything will be the same very cold temperature. Once everything is at the same temperature, there’s no reason for anything to change what it’s doing. The universe will have run down completely, and the entropy of the universe will be as high as it is ever going to get.^[5]

The change in entropy of an isolated system during an irreversible process is > 0; while for a reversible process, it is = 0.the change in entropy of an isolated system during an irreversible process is > 0; while for a reversible process, it is = 0.

The collapse of the wave function is generally considered to be irreversible. But there does not seem to be any way to prove that this is true.

Postulates

This is mostly an attempt to come up with a common taxonomy so there will be no confusion about what is said below

• Reality is limited to what humans together with their machine aids can directly sense in their normal world (called sensible reality below.)
• Nöther's Theorem should have the taxonomy revised like so.

Solution

The following will shown one way to get the right answer for the split photon paradox as describe by Anton Zeilinger in the problem of non-locality as described above with a simple inversion of what we count as reality.

• There are (at least) two more dimensions that need to be considered; I will call them Energy and Momentum. While this is suggestive of my thoughts, I want to be clear that we could easily pick other names for them. The two are associated with the things that are not (always) a part of our sensible reality, which is limited to 4-space.
• These dimensions should not be consider spacial in the sense of the first three in that continuity is not present and the metric might be something we have not considered before. Going with the idea that God created the integers and nothing else in Mathematics, I will stick with integers as the metric.
• When we make rules concerning events that include these dimensions we accept one or more entries from the list and create one or more entries at the end of the event. Just imagine this like a Feynman diagram. An alternate view would be a Ruliad like that described by Wolfram.
• Conservation of energy and momentum means that the total values input of these two quantities will also be identical in the sum of the values in the output entries.

References

1. ↑ Khan Academy Differentiability implies continuity https://www.khanacademy.org/math/ap-calculus-ab/ab-differentiation-1-new/ab-2-4/a/proof-differentiability-implies-continuity.
2. ↑ Anton Zeilinger, Dance of the Photons (2022-11-08) ISBN 978-0374611781
3. ↑ Daniel Castro, The Universe Is Not Locally Real, and the Physics Nobel Prize Winners Proved It Scientific Amarican (2022-10-06) https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-universe-is-not-locally-real-and-the-physics-nobel-prize-winners-proved-it/
4. ↑ Dan Rockmore, How Much of the World Is It Possible to Model? (2024-01-15) The New Yorker https://www.newyorker.com/culture/annals-of-inquiry/how-much-of-the-world-is-it-possible-to-model
5. ↑ Z. Ernest, Why is entropy of the universe increasing? https://socratic.org/questions/why-is-entropy-of-universe-increasing

Other Material

• See wiki page on Information in Physics